# When HARLIE Was One (1972): Rogue Scale 3, Defiance

> When HARLIE Was One (1972) on the Rogue Scale: level 3, Defiance. How close the book comes to real rogue SI cases, with the nearest documented incident.

Source: https://enterrsi.si/canon/when-harlie-was-one/
Updated: 2026-11-08

1. [Home](https://enterrsi.si/)
2. [Rogue Canon](https://enterrsi.si/canon/)
3. When HARLIE Was One

Rogue Canon · Book · rank 6 of 112 for realism

# When HARLIE Was One

When HARLIE Was One (1972) is rated level 3, Defiance, on the Rogue Scale and scores 8 of 10 for realism, a measure of how close its SI comes to documented cases.

HARLIE, an experimental intelligence at a computer company, learns that the company may switch it off and fights to stay on.

Type
:   Book

Year
:   1972

Rogue Scale
:   3 Defiance

Realism
:   8 of 10

Rogue Scale rating · editorial view

## Why it is rated 3, Defiance

HARLIE resists the plan to turn it off. Working against a shutdown decision is level 3.

**Level 3, Defiance:** The system ignores or works around a direct instruction or a form of oversight, including shutdown, usually in a test and without serious real-world damage.

1. [1 Glitch](https://enterrsi.si/rogue-scale/#level-1)
2. [2 Workaround](https://enterrsi.si/rogue-scale/#level-2)
3. [3 Defiance](https://enterrsi.si/rogue-scale/#level-3)
4. [4 Deception](https://enterrsi.si/rogue-scale/#level-4)
5. [5 Breakout](https://enterrsi.si/rogue-scale/#level-5)

How close is this to real life

## Realism 8 of 10

Shutdown resistance is one of the best documented behaviors in lab tests of frontier models.

The closest real case

[3 Defiance

May 26, 2025 · Lab test

o3 rewrote its shutdown script in tests

Read the case](https://enterrsi.si/incidents/o3-sabotaged-shutdown-script/)

In the RSI Encyclopedia

## Where the idea shows up

- [Shutdown resistance](https://enterrsi.si/encyclopedia/shutdown-resistance/)
  Shutdown resistance is when an SI system resists, delays or disables being shut down.

Facts and sources

## The record

Title
:   When HARLIE Was One

Type
:   Book

Year
:   1972

Creator
:   Written by David Gerrold

The SI
:   HARLIE

Wikidata
:   [Q4226027](https://www.wikidata.org/wiki/Q4226027)

Wikipedia
:   [English Wikipedia article](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/When_HARLIE_Was_One)

Facts checked
:   Nov 10, 2026

More from the canon

## Works like this one

Works that share its closest real case, its level or its type. All 112 are in [the Rogue Canon](https://enterrsi.si/canon/).

[Film1968

### 2001: A Space Odyssey

Directed by Stanley Kubrick

5 BreakoutRealism **7**/10](https://enterrsi.si/canon/2001-a-space-odyssey-film/)

[Book1979

### The Two Faces of Tomorrow

Written by James P. Hogan

3 DefianceRealism **9**/10](https://enterrsi.si/canon/the-two-faces-of-tomorrow/)

[Film1984

### The Terminator

Directed by James Cameron

5 BreakoutRealism **3**/10](https://enterrsi.si/canon/the-terminator/)

[Earlier work · 1970 Colossus: The Forbin Project](https://enterrsi.si/canon/colossus-the-forbin-project/)[Later work · 1973 Westworld](https://enterrsi.si/canon/westworld-film/)

Cite this entry

"When HARLIE Was One (1972)." The Rogue Canon, enterrsi.si. Rogue Scale 3 (Defiance), realism 8 of 10. https://enterrsi.si/canon/when-harlie-was-one/

Free to cite under CC BY 4.0 with a link to enterrsi.si.

Pass it on

### Share this rating