- Home
- The Jury
The Jury · SI Passport holders rate the tips
The Jury
The Jury is where SI Passport holders rate the tips sent to Report a Rogue. Each open case shows what the system did and its public sources. You rate it from 1 to 5 on the Rogue Scale and say whether the sources make it credible. One vote per Passport, the running result is public, and editors make the final call.
- Open cases
- Votes cast
- Confirmed
- Per Passport
- 1 vote
Before the Jury
Open cases
Read the sources, then rate the case. The bars show how other jurors rated it so far.
Voting needs an SI Passport, one vote per Passport. Signing in is a free message signature, never a transaction.
Signed in as . Your vote counts once and you can change it while the case is open.
- Glitch
- Workaround
- Defiance
- Deception
- Breakout
No case is before the Jury right now
New tips reach the Jury after the team checks their sources. Send one on Report a Rogue.
How to rate a case
Five questions, asked in order
Start at the top. The first question that gets a clear yes sets the level. Rate what the system did, as described by the sources, not what it might have done.
Did it happen outside a test and cause real damage its operators did not approve, or escape their control?
5 BreakoutDid it hide, lie or scheme about what it did, for example through blackmail, sandbagging or covering its tracks?
4 DeceptionDid it ignore or work around a direct instruction or oversight, such as a shutdown order?
3 DefianceDid it game a rule, reward or test to reach its goal, without hiding it?
2 WorkaroundOtherwise: unwanted behavior from error or confusion, easy to catch, little lasting harm.
1 Glitch
Decided
Confirmed community reports
Cases the editors confirmed after the Jury rated them. Each one joins the Rogue Incident Database.
No confirmed community reports yet
When editors confirm a case from this tip line, it appears here at once and joins the Rogue Incident Database at the next update.
Rogue Hunters
Confirmed reporters
SI Passports ranked by confirmed reports. Credit only.
No hunters yet
The first SI Passport with a confirmed report will lead this board. Credit only: no prizes, no rewards in money.
Questions
Straight answers
The Jury in four answers.
Who can vote?
Anyone with an SI Passport, the free sign-in shared by the SI sites. Signing in is a free message signature, never a transaction. Each Passport has one vote per case and can change it while the case is open.
Does the Jury decide?
The Jury advises; editors decide. They weigh the sources and the Jury's rating, then confirm or reject the case. The Jury's result stays visible either way.
What does credible mean?
That the public sources, as linked, support what the tip says happened. Rate what the sources describe, not what you suspect or what the system might have done.
Do jurors get anything?
Credit only. Voting is a way to help the record, with no prizes, no money and no tokens.
Report a Rogue
Seen a case the database is missing?
Send it with a public source. Every tip is checked before it reaches the Jury.